The Abuser’s Entitlement To Marriage

“You are not entitled to a happy marriage”. I heard and read some variation of these words countless times when I was going through my divorce. I’ll admit they caused me pause every time, and they still do. They are true, after all. Not everyone gets to have happiness in their marriage, and some people don’t even get to be married at all. But in the context of divorce, this can be a really cruel way to try and motivate people to stay in a marriage. At least, it can when there have been serious transgressions.

I agree that becoming dissatisfied with a spouse is no reason to seek divorce. Happiness in a marriage doesn’t just happen: it takes work from both individuals. When that work isn’t done, unhappiness and dissatisfaction will be the result. The answer isn’t to throw in the towel, but rather to do some pretty hard self-examination and work on building up the relationship.

But in a destructive, abusive relationship these words are something else entirely. You are telling a person who wants peace and safety that he or she is having entitlement issues. Only someone with a very dispassionate attitude toward other humans could label “I want to go to sleep knowing that I will be safe” as “entitlement”. It’s a cruel twist of words, but they can easily bring shame to the peacemaker who is doing his or her best to stay safe, emotionally, spiritually, and physically.

What I’ve found ironic as I’ve listened to stories of abuse victims, however, is that the aggressor is afforded a great deal of entitlement by many churches. He or she is entitled to a marriage, whether the victim wants out or not. I was re-reading John Piper’s take on abusive marriages and I came across these words:

A wife’s submission to the authority of civil law, for Christ’s sake, may, therefore, overrule her submission to a husband’s demand that she endure his injuries. This legitimate recourse to civil protection may be done in a spirit that does not contradict the spirit of love and submission to her husband, for a wife may take this recourse with a heavy and humble heart that longs for her husband’s repentance and the restoration of his nurturing leadership.

Leaving aside the whole issue that apparently a wife is only able to “not submit” to her husband because the civil authorities protect her (rather than realizing a wife is never required to submit “to a husband’s demand that she endure his injuries”), even when a wife flees to protect herself she is to long for the marriage to be restored. The only conclusion I can draw from this is that her husband, no matter how much evil he has done, is entitled to be married to her.

This really hit home as I read a letter from a “former abuser” on ACFJ this week. The part that really got my ire up was his last words:

I am not ready to give up the fight of my life, or my marriage of about 35 years, or my family just yet.

By his own admission, this man abused his wife. He harmed her so much that she decided to end the marriage. He claims repentance, and yet he still believes that the marriage is his to fight for. It is “the fight of his life”. But the real fight of our lives is to be called sons and daughters of God, a right we can never secure on our own; Jesus did it for us. The point is, repentance is not a means to an end. It is not the pathway by which we get things back that we have destroyed.

In the (in my opinion misnamed) parable of the Prodigal Son, there is a son who leaves and a son who stays. The son who stays puts great stock in his own behavior, seeing it as a means to gain his inheritance. But he is not grateful for the presence of his father, something he had the entire time. Ironically, it is the son who squandered what he had who learns the value of the father’s presence. He was willing serve in the lowest of positions just to have it.

That is the attitude of repentance. Whenever someone says “I’ve repented, so now . . .” he or she is already wrong. The gift we get from repentance is the forgiveness and grace of Christ. Anything else we demand means we are feeling entitled.

Abusers have a spirit of entitlement. They believe there are certain things that are their rights, and sadly the church plays right along. The loophole is wanting a marriage to stick it out isn’t entitlement in so many Christians eyes because they reason that God always wants marriages to succeed. But this is false: God does care more for victims than he does for marriages. Take the metaphor of God’s relationship with Israel: Scripture says that God issued Israel a writ of divorce for her transgressions. Would any of us accept Israel turning around and saying “I’m sorry, I’ve stopped my idolatrous behavior, now God you must take me back”? Never- under such logic Israel was owed the crucifixion rather than it being an act of grace. Israel was never entitled to be received back by God after he reached the end of his patience.

The woman fleeing the husband abusing her? She’s not waving around the “R” word to try to get something. She’s exercising healthy self preservation. Please do not even hint that her act is one of entitlement. Save that for the abuser who believes it’s time for her to come home.

About Jeff S

Programmer, musician, father, and lover of Jesus. I have a strong passion to see people free from abuse and religion misused so that they can find the ultimate empowered life in Jesus.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to The Abuser’s Entitlement To Marriage

  1. Victoria says:

    Thanks Jeff! Words like these need to continually be spoken to undo all of the wounds that self-righteous beliefs have caused. Its a mess that needs truth spoken over it!
    I still struggle with the doubt, “was it me??? How can so many “professional” Christians (read pastors) have it wrong?”. But then, truth comes… it is crazy to think that God gets any glory from someone being destroyed by one who claims the name of Christ (no less one called to “love as Christ”). It is crazy to think that God would EVER want one of his precious children to live in such an awful state, no less raise small children in a home so completely full of sin where the only one being loved or honored is the one bullying everyone else. Its absurd to think that children raised in this kind of backward environment would somehow be more blessed than a child who has been protected from calling evil good.
    Even after being set free from this kind of life, I still struggle to keep my mind free as my heart heals… Thank you for speaking truth! God bless you!


    • Jeff S says:

      Thanks Victoria. I share the same struggles and worries. And the thing is, if I step back and read some of these doctrines, they sound crazy. I mean, there really shouldn’t be any question about divorce for abuse. It’s not something to argue over. Those outside the faith know it and can see it clearly. We have some bad thought patterns that discredit the Cross, but more and more I’m encouraged that I think people are wising up.


  2. jhintze says:

    Very bravely written and I wholeheartedly agree! I think I’ve been wondering if you’d ever write something along these lines. I respect you and I’m proud of you, not that you need that from me, but there it is.


  3. dpersson7 says:

    This was encouraging to read. I was divorced over thirty years ago and at that time the only correct answer to what I should do was, “God hates divorce.” When I went for counseling, if you could call it that, I was never asked any questions to find out why I left, I was just told that I should seek to be reconciled. My parents stepped in and basically told me if I went back and my ex abandoned me again, I was on my own. He vanished for over six weeks and left me with no money, no transportation, and we had a young child. The abandonment was only one of many problems, but adultery and abuse were also there. (Just sharing this to show how extreme the situation was) It took several years before I found a church in which I didn’t feel condemned for being divorced, but I carried around the guilt for decades because Christians don’t get divorced even if it is in the best interest of the child. Anyway, I am not angry at my ex he was just as messed up as I was, but I do struggle with the callousness of some pastors. If any of them had even given me an opportunity to at least explain the situation there may have been some hope of healing, but instead there was just an assumption that I was looking for an easy way out. I wasn’t, I just needed help, which of course not one of them offered. Sorry, this hit a nerve for me. Thirty plus years after the fact and I still get angry about it. I hate to see people damaged by the careless theology of some.


    • Jeff S says:

      The church response to my divorce was the hardest part. It was worse than the death of the relationship. I guess because I’d already processed a lot of the grief of the divorce before it happened and over several years. But I do recall the feeling very acutely that if I ever met a Christian and things were pleasant, I was always waiting for the other shoe to drop and being rejected. Like I was constantly tense expecting the hit to come at any time.

      Church was very hard for me for a while. I was very fortunate to eventually land in a church that was supportive of me- the pastor had survived a wife who had died. He didn’t resonate with the divorce part, but he did with the grief of losing the relationship, and that made him very compassionate toward me. Also finding ACFJ helped a lot, because there was acceptance without feeling like I had to give up my faith.

      The sad thing was, people outside my church saw my marriage so clearly, but I wouldn’t listen to them. It’s sad, because areas like these are where we need our faith community to surround us the most. I’ve been encouraged to see more positive conversations happening around divorce, though, and I feel like a lot of churches are waking up to how poorly divorce, especially in abuse cases, has been handled in the past.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s